We like our ice cream sandwiches messy. They just taste better that way. The cookies that we make are perfect for soaking up ice cream as it melts on a hot summer day and they’re just as substantially flavored.
Year Round Favorites
Vanilla Ice Cream + Chocolate Chip Oatmeal Cookies
Our revamped version of one of the quintessential ice cream sandwiches. Our Chocolate Chip Oatmeal Cookies are made with two kinds of chocolate bits, ground oatmeal for a chewy texture, and a pop of cinnamon. This provides the perfect compliment to the pure bourbon vanilla flavor of our ice cream.
Peanut Butter Ice Cream + Double Chocolate Chip Cookies
For the die-hard chocolate and peanut butter lovers. Our Double Chocolate Chip Cookies are made with high quality cocoa, melted chocolate, and semi-sweet chocolate chips. A generous scoop of our Peanut Butter Ice Cream, made with Edward Freeman Nut Company’s peanut butter, is then sandwiched between these supremely rich cookies.
Vanilla Ice Cream + Salted Toffee Almond Grahams
A Zsa’s signature, the idea for this sandwich began with a family favorite gooey graham cracker concoction that just needed to have ice cream paired with it. Graham crackers are coated with butter and brown sugar toffee, sprinkled with slivered almonds, and finished with a bit of Kosher salt before finally being sandwiched with our Vanilla Ice Cream.
Fall & Winter Seasonals
Pumpkin Ice Cream + Gingersnaps
A true sign that Fall has arrived in the Zsa’s kitchen. This sandwich is our Pumpkin Gingersnap Ice Cream in reverse! Rather than break up our chewy, seasonally spiced Gingersnaps to mix into our Pumpkin Ice Cream, we keep them whole and sandwich the Pumpkin Ice Cream between.
Peppermint Bark Ice Cream + Double Chocolate Chip Cookies
Our seasonally limited Peppermint Bark Ice Cream is sandwiched with our rich Double Chocolate Chip Cookies and then rolled in crushed organic candy canes.
Spring & Summer Seasonals
Lemon Buttermilk Ice Cream + Candied Ginger Shortbread
A particularly refreshing combo in hot weather, the creamy tartness of our Lemon Buttermilk Ice Cream pairs wonderfully with our buttery Shortbread cookies that are studded with sweet and zesty candied ginger.
Buttered Brown Sugar Peach Ice Cream + Pie Crust Cookies
A refined version of our Summer 2012 offering, this is our most favorite summer sandwich. It makes one think of sitting on a porch swing on a lazy summer evening and enjoying a piece of homemade peach pie a la mode. For this new version, we sandwich our butter and brown sugar poached peach ice cream between thin, mildly sweet Pie Crust Cookies and then finish with a dusting of sugar.